fbpx
Skip to main content

A Bridge at Vischer Ferry


Vischer Ferry Bridge 1901-1902
Photo provided by The Saratoga County History Roundtable.

Before the Northway, you would gain access to Clifton Park from the south by crossing the Mohawk River at either the Route 9 bridge to Crescent, or the Route 146 bridge to Rexford. These bridges existed since the early nineteenth century. Between these two bridges there were three ferries, Dunsbach Ferry, Forts Ferry, and Vischer Ferry. The most logical place for another bridge was at Vischer Ferry. This would provide direct access into the heart of Clifton Park.

The residents of Clifton Park wanted a bridge at Vischer Ferry ever since the Town was formed in 1828. An act to incorporate the Vischer’s Ferry Bridge Company was passed by the State legislature on April 19, 1828. Within two years a good and substantial bridge was to be constructed across the Mohawk River at some point within two hundred and fifty yards of Vischer’s Ferry. The width of the bridge was to be not less than twenty feet and was to be kept in good condition by the bridge Company.

The Act to incorporate the Vischer’s Ferry Bridge Company gave the company three years to erect the bridge, otherwise the corporation created by the Act would be dissolved. Evidently not enough investors could be found, as this bridge was never constructed.

The idea of having a bridge at Vischer Ferry did not die. In February 1900 engineers were busy taking soundings for the abutments of a proposed new bridge across the Mohawk at Vischer Ferry. This bridge, which was indeed erected, was 790 feet long, and cost $31,845, financed by local monies. 

In the spring of 1901, two sections of the bridge went out with the ice floods, and it was decided to raise the bridge some three feet. However, in 1902 the spring floods carried the entire bridge away before the job was completed. The total return on the investment was a toll collection of $1,300.

There was someone on the bridge when it went down. As the bridge began to vibrate and shake, he reversed his direction and made it to safety, just as the bridge collapsed into the river. A local newspaper gives his eye witness account.

The residents of Clifton Park petitioned the State legislature for a new bridge, and bills were introduced every year from 1910 to 1928 for the creation of such a bridge at a cost ranging from $75,000 to $370,000.

In a 1916 petition in support of the Vischer Ferry Bridge, the Town of Clifton Park indicated that the town and adjoining communities had suffered serious injury and hardship since the destruction of the bridge. “We have been deprived of all means of direct and convenient intercourse with the commercial centers to which we formerly carried our produce; the value of our property has been seriously depreciated, and we have suffered in respects too numerous to mention by reason of the failure of the state to erect a bridge thus far.”

The Town argued that Vischer Ferry is about halfway between Rexford and Crescent, and the natural converging point of all highways running through the Town of Clifton Park. Thus, it was a logical location for a proposed bridge. The ferry currently at that location could only be operated about seven months out of the year. The 1916 memorandum also indicated that a bridge would assist area fruit growers by placing them in direct communication over improved highways with Albany, Schenectady, Troy, Cohoes, and Watervliet.

In 1910 the bridge bill was passed by the Assembly but failed the Senate. The bills for 1912-1913 passed both houses but were vetoed by the Governor, and in 1915 it only passed the Assembly.

Even after the Canal Board investigated and determined that Vischer Ferry was the most advantageous location for the bridge, new bills introduced between 1918 and 1926 either died in committee or only passed one house.

In 1927 and 1928 both Saratoga County and Schenectady County each appropriated funds for a bridge, but the state was not forthcoming with the remainder. By 1929 a new bridge bill indicated that the bridge at Vischer Ferry would be erected wholly at the cost of the State. This change from previous legislation dividing the expense between the State and counties of Schenectady and Saratoga was a result of Governor Roosevelt’s endorsement of a plan to convert old canal lands on the north side of the river into a public park.

The question of a bridge at Vischer Ferry seems to have finally died about 1934. It appears that Saratoga County was to benefit more than Schenectady County and when additional funding from Schenectady County was sought, it was not forthcoming. Also, additional legislation for the bridge never seemed to get out of Committee.

Had the bridge been erected, the character of Clifton Park would have been quite different. Development would have occurred much earlier and in different areas from the post Northway boom. Those of us who now reside in Vischer Ferry would probably have had an address of Vischer Ferry Estates South, and the Greek Revival architecture and canal history that we are so familiar with would truly be memories of the past.

Life’s Fleeting Breath: An Epitaph for Jeremiah Clark

Jeremiah Clark 1783-1844. 
Photo provided by The Saratoga County History Roundtable.

The small rural cemetery that sits along Clark Road in Providence silently beckoned me to stop and visit as it came into view one Autumn morning. I was happy to oblige, hoping to be rewarded with a glimpse of insight from these final reminders that mark the end of the life of those who, like us, also once smelled the fragrance of autumn and felt the warmth of the midday sun.

One stone, which stands out by the bright circular spot on the upper left, immediately caught my eye. When I got closer, I read that it marked the grave of lifelong Providence resident and farmer Jeremiah Clark. Though 177 years have passed since he was laid to rest, on the stone can still be read the details of his life: a birth on March 29, 1783, and a death 61 years, 3 months, and 19 days later, on July 18, 1844.

On the lower half of the stone there is this epitaph, well-worn from the passage of time and now barely readable:

Could Friends have stayed the dart of death, While watching by thy side; Could Love recall life’s fleeting breath, Thou would’st not sure have died. Affection, powerless to save, Could only weep above thy grave.

Jeremiah Clark was the son of William V. Clark, one of the early residents of the town of Providence, Saratoga County. His father had left Dutchess County, New York in 1790 and settled on a farm along what is now Clark Road just west of the cemetery that carries the family name. By 1807, his son, 24-year-old Jeremiah was married to nineteen-year-old Polly Van Ness, and the first of their four children had been born. Two years later Jeremiah purchased from his older brother, Benedict Arnold Clark, one-half interest in a fulling mill along Alden Creek (now known as Alder Creek.) In 1815 together they purchased ninety-four acres of woodland in the twenty-first allotment of the Kaderosseras patent, possibly for timber for the sawmill that they built on their property along Alden Creek. Jeremiah again added to his land holdings when he purchased holdings in 1822 when he purchased an additional 153 acres in the same allotment.

At the time of Jeremiah’s death in 1844, his son, William V. took over the mill property, which was by then known as the Clark Sawmill. Along with operating the sawmill, William V. Clark served the community as Supervisor for the town of Providence seven times from 1848 to 1875. After Jeremiah passed away his wife Polly continued to live on their farm just south of the intersection of Clark Road on the west side of Antioch Road. Polly Clark lived to be 83 years old and is buried next to Jeremiah in the Clark Cemetery. On the 1856 Geil map of Providence, the Clark Sawmill property along Alden Creek is at the top center of the map; William’s farm on Clark Road is in the center and Jeremiah and Polly’s farm is along Antioch Road at the bottom.

Jeremiah’s epitaph was taken from the poem “Stanzas on the Death of Miss Rebecca Ann Marshall.” Surprisingly, it is possible to determine where whoever chose it for his gravestone had learned of this poem as the only time it was published before his death was in the January 1842 issue of Godey’s Ladies Book.

Godey’s, a monthly woman’s magazine that was the most widely circulated periodical in America before the Civil War. The poem was written by Emma Catherine Embury, a prolific author and poet from Brooklyn, New York, who likely was acquainted with Rebecca Ann and her family. While there is no record of Rebecca’s age when she passed away on August 21, 1841, the poem is written to commemorate a life cut short.

For the epitaph of Jeremiah Clark, only a portion of one stanza was taken from the four-stanza poem. When you read the complete stanza below it is understandable why the three lines were left out when being used to commemorate the life of this sixty-one-year-old farmer.

Could Friends have stayed the dart of death, While watching by thy side; Could Love recall life’s fleeting breath, Thou would’st not sure have died. But thou wert hurried to the tomb In all the flush of beauty’s bloom, In all thy youthful pride; Affection, powerless to save, Could only weep above thy grave.

Neither Rebecca Ann nor Jeremiah lived lives that brought them into the limelight of history, one as her life was cut short and the other from being someone who lived a simple life providing for himself and his family. The lesson that I learned in all of this is that each life story, no matter how short or simple, speaks of a person, someone who lived and breathed the same as we do today. Taking time to consider those who came before us, famous or obscure, can enrich our lives when we take time to delve into the stories these men and women have been left behind.

Dave Waite is a resident of Blue Corners, Saratoga County and is a photographer and videographer.  He has written many articles on upstate New York history, including several in the recently published book, More Saratoga County Stories. Dave can be reached at davewaitefinearts@gmail.com 

Saratoga County’s 1898 Leadership Battle

The recent battle for Speaker of the United States House of Representatives left many astounded that it took so many votes to reach a conclusion. However, Saratoga County once went through a situation that makes the House of Representatives battle look like very small potatoes. It must be noted that Saratoga County was a bastion for the Republican Party since its inception in 1856, and generally voted for the Whig Party before that. The situation changed in 1898, although it is unknown what spurred the change. It could have been the Financial Panic of 18933 or the Spanish American War or some much more local issue that is lost to the minds of the modern citizen.

The makeup of the County was different in 1898. Neither Saratoga Springs nor Mechanicville had been chartered as cities. Saratoga Springs was still a Town and Mechanicville was just a railroad head included in the Boundaries of Halfmoon and Stillwater. Thus, there were just 20 Towns in the County, and since the advent of weighted voting was still 75 years away, each supervisor would cast one vote at meetings of the Saratoga County Board of Supervisors. 

This became a problem in 1898 when the voters elected 10 Republicans and 10 Democrats to the Board. Republicans represented Clifton Park, Corinth, Day, Greenfield, Hadley, Halfmoon, Moreau, Northumberland, Saratoga Springs, and Wilton. Democrats held the Town Supervisor positions in Charlton, Ballston, Edinburg, Galway, Malta, Milton, Providence, Saratoga, Stillwater, and Waterford. The scene was set for an epic struggle for leadership.

The Organizational Meeting was set for 4 p.m. on Monday, Nov. 14, 1898. The meeting began innocently enough with the Clerk of the Board calling the roll and asking each Supervisor to state his choice for Chairman. Ten Supervisors voted for Walter Cavert, D-Charlton and 10 voted for George Jackson, R – Moreau. The Clerk took 38 more votes, but there was no change in the outcome. Finally, on the motion of Frank Hathorn, the meeting was adjourned until the next day.

The Board was called to order the next day at 10 a.m. J Howard Arnold moved that the voting be done by written ballots. I assume he intended to free Supervisors from being strongarmed by their respective parties. However, the clerk called the roll for several more ballots , but after 53 votes, the chamber remained deadlocked.

When the Board reconvened on Wednesday, Nov. 16, it seemed like Groundhog Day. Seven more votes were taken with no change.  In the afternoon, Frank Hathorn tried to break the impasse by proposing that each party name one member to a special committee to confer and propose a plan of organization. The resolution was blocked by the Democrats. Finally, after the 102nd fruitless vote they adjourned for the day.

On Thursday, they took just one vote, the 103rd, with the results again tied 10 to 10. After four hours of arguing, they all agreed to establish a four-man committee. George Valentine and William Donnelly represented the Democrats while Clarence Griffin and Frank Hathorn were selected by the Republicans.  The next morning they reported that they were still deadlocked and the Democrats argued that they had the right to reorganize the Board since they had actually received more votes than the Republicans in the last election. The Republicans, of course rejected the assertion. At 1:30 p.m., there appeared to be a breakthrough with a compromise offered by Frank Hathorn. The terms were as follows:          

Democrats to appoint the Chair and Republicans to appoint the Clerk to the Board; Parties were to split appointments of the Jail Physician and County Home physician; The Chair and memberships of Standing Committees divided equally; Official printing to be divided equally between the parties.

It looked like the stalemate might be resolved before the weekend and a four-man committee was established with instructions that they report back to the Board that afternoon with a final resolution. However, after asking twice for more time, the Board finally agreed to give them the evening to work out the details and adjourned to Saturday morning. 

If the devil is in the details, this devil was exceedingly strong.  While there was general agreement on most of the issues, negotiations broke down over the makeup of the standing committees, and both sides accused the other of bad faith bargaining. After some testy personal exchanges, they took more fruitless votes and after the 110th unsuccessful vote, they adjourned to Monday, Nov. 21.

At the beginning of the 2nd week of this marathon struggle, the Democrats put forth a long resolution to explain why they were unwilling to accept Supervisor Hathorn’s proposal for organization and also would not accept his offer to give the terms offered to them to the Republicans. The resolution also offered more than a few personal attacks, and was obviously rejected by the Republican members of the Board. The positions of the two sides hardened and the rest of the session was taken up with more unsuccessful 10-10 votes through ballot 155.  They met daily through Saturday, Nov. 26, continuing the unsuccessful run of votes through ballot 360.

Finally, on Nov. 28, the Democrats revisited Supervisor Hathorn’s proposal of Nov. 18, and decided they could accept it, provided the Chair of the Board had the full power to act in the performance of his duties. The long nightmare was ended, and Walter Cavert of Charlton was unanimously elected as the first Democratic Chairman of the Board.

In all, the Board of Supervisors had deliberated for two weeks, worked through the Thanksgiving holiday, and taken 361 votes before even getting to one piece of the people’s business. The Board stayed in session for another 20 days, finally adjourning for the year on Dec. 23.

The Democrats attained an actual majority in 1899 and kept it for a couple of years. With the advent of the 20th century, Republicans recaptured a majority and have held it ever since. Thus, there have been no repeats of the crazy organization battle of 1898. This story is based on the official proceedings of the Board of Supervisors. What really happened behind closed doors is lost in the mists of time, but one can only imagine the horse trading that actually went on!

Dave Wickerham has had a long-term interest in the political history of Saratoga County.  He served as an employee of Saratoga County for more than 33 years, including 25 years as County Administrator

Bacon Hill – Not Forgotten

“Why not Bacon Hill?”  Within days of the Saratoga County History Center’s release of our first video in a new series, entitled “Forgotten Crossroads – Rock City Falls” in April 2022 two board members approached me with a suggestion for our next video. We had envisioned this multi- film project as a way for the History Center at Brookside Museum to bring attention to the many small hamlets within Saratoga County with a long history, but now largely by-passed by the economic and transportation revolution of the last 100 years. In a county dissected by the Adirondack Northway 60 years ago, and today mostly known for the shining resort of Saratoga Springs, and the sprouting housing developments of Clifton Park, Wilton and other growing towns, this series was meant to highlight those small communities long since forgotten.

Our first indication that these assumptions did not tell the whole story was during the filming of Rock City Falls. Yes, it had a long history, yes it no longer was the home of many large paper mills powered by the Kayaderosseras Creek gurgling through its center. No longer was there an electric railway to transport workers and the goods they produced to Ballston Spa and its connection to the larger outside world. But we soon realized that the hamlet was still a living, breathing crossroads. Residents still took pride in their community, its two churches and its volunteer firehouse. Local men and women still worked in the remaining mill, Cottrell Paper Company. The Manson Inn still attracted visitors for social events. Surprised by this vitality, we closed the film with a segment entitled “The Community Still Lives.”

But Bacon Hill? What was there about Bacon Hill that could possibly result in a similar uplifting ending? How could we produce a 20-minute video about these fields dotted with a few farms, one church and a blueberry patch? Well, my first impression was correct in one regard. It was indeed impossible to create a 20-minute video on Bacon Hill.

I should have suspected as much at our first meeting with a few residents in July 2022. Pat Peck, not even a resident of Bacon Hill but heir to the Peck family legacy, sent me a list of Bacon Hill folks who might be interested in working on the project. She provided me with background on each one and who was related to whom. That was my first clue that this film would be different. We assembled in the King Brothers Dairy, the only retail establishment in Bacon Hill, a convenience store well known for its milk and ice cream. In walked several people, all of an age, but seemly excited to be part of this project. They brought scrapbooks, photo albums, pamphlets and brochures. That was my second clue.

The stories were my third clue. They had lots of stories. Unprompted by myself they excitedly related their stories to me, a total stranger. As one of our interviewees later stated about another Bacon Hill icon since passed, “They knew everything about everybody.” And the stories, for the most part, were not gossipy tales of their neighbors. They were positive snapshots of the people and families of Bacon Hill, drawing from their memories to recall events in their own lives and those of their relatives and friends, sometimes going back generations.

I was elated by that first visit, but something told me not to get “over my skis.” Oral narratives by people long enjoying the retirement life are great, but was there more to the community? Would the next generation, many in their 50’s immersed in their work, want to share their own stories with this amateur film director and our videographer, Dave Waite? Would they be willing to carve out some time from their busy schedule to contribute to this small locally- produced video? After all, time is money, you know.

When we discovered that the answer to these questions was a resounding yes, we knew we had something. They were gracious and outgoing, eager to talk of their success and challenges, but also proud of their heritage and their families. As one might imagine if you know anything about Bacon Hill, we interviewed several Pecks and Kings. The Peck family first arrived in Bacon Hill in 1836 and two of the largest farms – Welcome Stock and Clear Echo – are owned by 6th generation descendants of the original settler. One of the co-owners of Welcome Stock is Willard “Billy” Peck, the current Northumberland Town Supervisor.

The Kings are relative newcomers, having only been in Bacon Hill for 120 years or so. They are well known for their commercial dairy operation and the aforesaid Kings Dairy store. Edgar King, recently deceased, was also a town supervisor and led the communities’ farms first movement in the 1990s. His sons Jeff and Jan currently own both the dairy and Kings-Ransom farm.

Of course, there are people in Bacon Hill not named Peck or King.  Jen Thomas of Thomas Poultry and Brian Carmer of StoneBridge Iron and Steel each had a story to tell. All of our interviews were unique but common themes emerged. Proud of their accomplishments, all were quick to give credit to the hard work and innovation of past generations. And all were genuinely excited about the future.

We also interviewed Byron Winney, owner of the Winney Blueberry Farm who sadly passed away soon after we had the good fortune to talk with him. The Bacon Hill Reformed Church is the center of the community, both literally and figuratively. Pastor Jan Vincent and church member Nancy Purinton related their 200 yearlong history and spoke of their vision for the future.

One final surprise awaited us. Impressed by the response of leaders of the middle generation, what could we expect from their sons and daughters? One hint came from one of our earliest interviews with Jeff King and his son Johnathan. A young man just graduated from Cornell, the college of choice for generations of Bacon Hill farmers, he was “all in” to embark on the career path of his parents and grandparents. In our last session we talked with Jan King, joined by his wife Pandora Davis, and teenagers Hannah and Nate. You may surmise the results but the best way to confirm your suspicions would be to attend one of the film’s premiere events.

Thursday, March 30, 7 p.m. at Brookside Museum in Ballston Spa (sold out), Thursday, April 20, 7 p.m. at the Bacon Hill Reformed Church, or Saturday, April 29, 2 p.m. at the Museum. Registration is suggested at https://brooksidemuseum.org/

Lefty Milligan: One of Saratoga’s Finest Athletes

John “Lefty” Milligan.
Photo provided by The Saratoga County History Roundtable.

When people think of Schuylerville, they think of history. The region is known for the 1777 Battles of Saratoga. Baseball is not what people think of Schuylerville. However, for years, the community was known for the pitcher John Milligan one of the finest athletes in the county’s history. He hurled for the Philadelphia Phillies of the National League and the Washington Senators of the American League. 

John Milligan was a noted Schuylerville High School athlete in basketball and baseball. In 1921 the Saratogian wrote, “Milligan has been pitching stellar ball all season.” Milligan then embarked to pitch at Cornell University. “Among the more promising new pitching prospects is John A. Milligan, left-hander, who performed brilliantly for the freshman team last year,” reported by Cornell Alumni News on March 20, 1924. 

Milligan batted left-handed and threw right-handed. The Boston Daily Globe reported on May 4, 1924, “John Milligan, a stocky southpaw, had the [Harvard] Crimson battery eating out of his hands throughout.” Milligan played two seasons for Cornell. He was instrumental in starting at triple play against Columbia and pitching a no-hit game against Virginia which he lost 1 to 0 because he gave too many bases on balls. 

Milligan continued to play ball in Schuylerville. The Saratogian reported on July 15, 1924 that the “Veterans Royal Giants of Albany… composed of (many) colored [sic] players have arranged to represent Schuylerville for the remainder of the baseball season. The team comes here highly recommended, and the games should prove a great attraction for the village… John Mulligan, a baseball pitcher for Cornell College will pitch with the outfit… The opening game will be played Sunday with the Mechanicville K. of C. team at the Fort Hardy Park diamond.”

Milligan’s first major league game was on August 11, 1928 for the Philadelphia Phillies (1928–1931). The New York Times reported the next day that Philadelphia lost to the New York Giants 4–0. “The Phils played a mean trick on a young fellow named Jack Milligan yesterday at the Polo Grounds. The youth hadn’t caught his breath from the excitement of being in the major leagues when he was flung to the fury of the Giants, a team that was practically invincible the way it played yesterday. Young Mr. Milligan was hired yesterday morning and fired at the Giants in the afternoon. He never had a chance.” 

“Johnnie Milligan, Schuylerville lad, yesterday (September 24, 1930) turned in his first major league victory, when, pitching for the Philadelphia club of the National League, he turned back Brooklyn, 6 to 3… His chief weakness has been his inability to control the ball, his wildness having cost him a regular pitching assignment with the Phillies. The New York baseball authors with the Brooklyn team gave Milligan a lot of credit for winning the match. The New York Times said: “The Dodgers… could not solve the efficient pitching of Jack Milligan, a southpaw. Milligan, whose hurling this year won a pennant for the Wilkes-Barre club, for which he turned in twenty victories.” The New York Tribune said: “Milligan pitched as though he might be the answer to many Philadelphia prayers for a pitcher. Aside from the first inning, he never gave the Robins much chance to do any hitting, and in the few times they did get men on the bases, he stopped them cold,” according to the Saratogian on September 25, 1930. 

Milligan’s final game was on June 23, 1934 with the Washington Senators. In a five-season career, Milligan posted a 3–8 record with 38 strikeouts and a 5.17 ERA in 35 appearances, including 12 starts, four complete games, and 116⅔ innings of work. Milligan played professionally with Newark, Baltimore, Buffalo, Albany, and Toronto in the International League; Syracuse, Wilkes-Barre, Scranton, and Albany of the New York¬–Penn League; Nashville of the Southern Association; Dayton of the Central League. 

Even as a professional ballplayer, Milligan found time to play local baseball. The Saratogian reported on October 9, 1933 that “’Lefty’ John Milligan, Schuylerville’s favorite son and ace port-sider for the Scranton team of the New York–Penn League, exercised his trusty wrong-side flipper with such effect yesterday that at the end of nine chuckers, the men of Easton had failed to acquire a semblance of a hit . . . Big John Milligan was in superb form and only on one occasion was he extended. His burning fastball, crackling curve, and deceptive change of pace completely overwhelmed the visitors, fourteen of whom were strikeout victims and none of whom collected anything close to a safe hit.”

After retiring from the diamond, Milligan took over the Broadway Theater in Schuylerville. In addition, Mulligan was a commercial pilot. In 1941, “Milligan demonstrated his skill in the cockpit by a successful takeoff from the state road (Route 9) at Round Lake. While State Police held back traffic for the stunt that was given approval by the Civil Aeronautics Authority,” according to the New York Times on November 7, 1942. In that year Mulligan was called on to serve the nation’s war effort by instructing military aircraft pilots at Carlstrom Field, Florida, operated by the Riddle Aeronautical Institute. After the war, he settled in Fort Pierce, Florida, where he died on May 15, 1972.   

Mulligan will be remembered in Schuylerville history for his athleticism. It seems fitting that on October 17, 1928, on the 151st anniversary of the surrender of Saratoga, the village of Schuylerville honored Milligan with a parade. “A local resident has said it never rains on 17 October. It poured instead last night. In spite of pouring the Schuylerville Fire Department Fife and Drum corps and citizens, automobiles escorted John A. Milligan Philadelphia National League baseball pitcher from the home of his parents on Green Street to the Hotel Schuyler, where 80 enthusiastic residents sat down to the dinner given under the auspices of the Chamber of Commerce to “Johnnie” or Lefty Milligan, as he is popularly known,” according to the Saratogian the following day.  

 Sean Kelleher is the historian for the Town of Saratoga, the vice president of the Saratoga County History Center, and the vice chairman of the Saratoga County 250th American Revolution Commission. Kelleher is a contributing writer to More Saratoga County Stories and Saratoga County Stories.

A Ballston Man on the “Other Side”

JM Bailey POW Parole of Honor.
Photo provided by The Saratoga County History Roundtable.

Over 160 years ago, 1861, our great Civil War was upon us in the United States. Pitting, in some cases, brother against brother, this war claimed more Americans than any other in which we have been involved.  Ballston was not exempt from participation in the war and sent many a man off to the fighting.  But one man, a staunch supporter of the Confederate cause, ended up in Ballston!

The Battle of Wilson’s Creek, probably a battle about which you have never heard, was fought on August 10, 1861 near Springfield, Missouri.  At about 5 AM Northern General Nathaniel Lyon, attacked the Confederates at Wilson’s Creek. Confederate forces soon rushed up and counterattacked the Union forces three times but failed to break through the Union lines. By 11 AM, the numerous attacks and counterattacks ended and a new Northern General Samuel Sturgis, realizing that his men were exhausted and his ammunition low, ordered a retreat to Springfield. The Confederates did not pursue and the battle ended.

Yes, there was a Ballston man there- well, a Ballston man-to-be.  J.M. Bailey was born in eastern Tennessee in 1841, moved to Arkansas, and, even though he was a “book-type” person, not the “fighting type,” he joined the Confederate troops and was at the Battle of Wilson’s Creek.  His unit never actually fought and, surprisingly, he was actually envious of those who did fight.  But, he witnessed the consequences of the fighting in which others in the group participated.  He would actually take part in a number of battles in later times.

J. M. Bailey recalled his days as a Confederate soldier in a 1929 Schenectady Gazette article recently uncovered in some files. That article indicated that Bailey had written his memoirs which are in the possession of an Arkansas library. In those memoirs, he talked of the change from the quiet of his country home to the excitement of being on the way to war.  And he spoke most proudly of the flag that flew with them, the flag of their new country, the Confederate States of America, the country that he and many others had pledged to defend.

The battles themselves were far less serene, according to his descriptions.  Shells flying on all sides; smoke totally obliterating any view of what was happening; summer heat made more intense because of heavy uniforms, thirst, and too few canteens to go around. 

But it got worse.  When all was again quiet, it was an eerie quiet.  He saw the dead everywhere; he saw faces “from which the lifeblood had ebbed away, stained…. with blood and dust….evidence that they fell on the firing line.”

And the dead were from both sides.  Bailey remembered one Union soldier whom he saw dying on the field, a man with what he called the “death pallor on his face.”  He could see that the man needed water and so, with great compassion as the man was from the “other” side, he held his own canteen so that the man could drink deeply, maybe the last drink he would ever have.

These were the scenes he remembered of the many battles Bailey would experience before his fighting years ended on the side that eventually lost its struggle for freedom.  Wilson’s Creek was the first major conflict west of the Mississippi River.  Troop strength in this battle was about 5,400 Union troops and 12,000 Confederates, not at all a small engagement.  The Confederate side was victorious and, during the battle, General Nathaniel Lyon was killed, the first Union general to die in combat in the war. 

But, there is more to the story. Uncovered a few years ago thanks to the records of the National Archives was a document that gives a greater glimpse into what happened to Bailey.  That document, pictured here, is his “Parole of Honor,” that is, his release from a Prisoner of War camp in 1865.  In that document he promises that he will never serve in the Confederate army again, never participate in any action against the United States of America again, and never render aid to enemies of the USA again.  It seems that, in 1865, Bailey, with his unit, moved from Minden LA to Shreveport LA to Marshall TX, where he and his group learned of Lee’s surrender.  He then went back to Shreveport as Federal troops arrived in order to surrender himself and get his “parole” papers.  It doesn’t seem that he was a prisoner for a very long time, as least by the way his memoirs are written.

So, how did he end up in Ballston? At some later point, he joined his relatives in Ballston, the Claude Bailey family, who started Fo’Castle Farms in Burnt Hills.   He wrote his memoirs so that his grandchildren, including Claude Moore Bailey of Burnt Hills, would know what his time in the Civil War had been like. And, thus, a Confederate soldier ended up in upstate New York!

A President’s Day Look at Martin Van Buren


Van Buren portrait as President. Photo provided.

This coming Monday we celebrate Presidents’ Day. The Federal holiday honors the 45 men who have attained the Office of The Presidency of the United States. It’s an ideal time to look at the remarkable life of Martin Van Buren. He was our eighth President and the first of six New York State residents to hold the office.

THE BEGINNINGS

Martin Van Buren’s life’s journey began less than 60 miles from here in Kinderhook, New York. The region, including Albany had been settled by immigrants from the Netherlands a century and a half before Martin was born. His date of birth was December 5, 1782. He was brought up in a home that spoke Dutch as its primary language. It would give him the distinction of being our only President to speak English as his second language.

Martin took a well travelled road to the political arena. He learned the law beginning at the age of 14 as a clerk at an attorney’s office. Seven years into his apprenticeship he passed the bar. The year was 1803. Martin Van Buren at the young age of 21 was on his way.

THE ASCENT TO POWER

Van Buren became known for his sharp mind and dapper attire. Soon he was considered one of upstate New York’s best courtroom attorneys. This distinction gave him a heads up for the nomination as a candidate for the State Senate in 1812. Although barely elected to the seat, Van Buren soon became a force to be reckoned with in the hotbed of New York State politics.

Five years later the Dutchman was elected Attorney General of The Empire State. In that post he became a leader of the state’s Democrat-Republicans, the forerunner of the Democratic Party.

In 1821 he was chosen by his peers as a United State senator. Of note, prior to the seventeenth amendment to the Constitution ratified in 1913, senators were voted in by their state legislatures. The senate seat gave Van Buren the keys to New York State’s thriving political machine. Although he was out of the state for long periods of time, he formed a group of partisans that controlled the spoils system in his absence. They became known as “The Albany Regency.”

It was in that time period Van Buren was labeled with a pair of nicknames that stayed with him throughout his career. He was called “The Little Magician” and “The Sly Fox.” The former was a reference to his diminutive size and unmatched political skills, the latter due to the red color of his hair and shrewd methods of governing.

Van Buren made his greatest political gift to the country in the early 1820s. He was instrumental in forming the Democratic Party. It was the beginning of our two party system. The long lasting effects are still in place almost two centuries later.

The 1828 presidential election was a turning point in Van Buren’s political career. He gave his unwavering support to the winning candidate, Andrew Jackson. In that same cycle Van Buren was elected as Governor of New York. His term began on January first, 1829. On March fourth Jackson became President. One of his first priorities was to name Van Buren as Secretary of State. He accepted the position after serving only 64 days as Governor. He quickly became a major player in international affairs. Later in Jackson’s first term, Van Buren served for a short time as Minister to Great Britain.

Jackson ran for a second term in 1832. Van Buren was his handpicked choice for number two man on the ticket. They easily won the election. “The Little Magician” spent the next four years as Vice-President.

With Jackson’s blessing, Van Buren became the unanimous choice as the Democratic Party’s candidate for President in 1836. He won the general election with ease. Much was expected from the wily politician when he was sworn in as our eighth President. It was his ill fortune to be confronted with the country’s first major depression only a few weeks into his administration. Van Buren would struggle with the calamity for his entire time in office. The old nicknames of respect were replaced by a new one.” Martin Van Ruin” became the rallying cry of his adversaries. There were positive results in his tenure, unfortunately not enough to halt the Nation’s financial crisis.

The bright star of Martin Van Buren was quickly fading.

After four years in the White House he was soundly defeated in his re- election bid. He had this to say about his tenure as Chief Executive.

“As to the Presidency, the two happiest days of my life were those of my entry upon the office and my surrender of it.” He promptly exited Washington,D.C. and headed home to Lindenwald, his estate in Kinderhook.

His term as President is hard to gauge. Being saddled with a nationwide financial disaster is a difficult, if not impossible obstacle for any leader to overcome. Though eminently qualified for the office, Herbert Hoover would learn the same lesson nearly a century later. As for Van Buren’s political skills as President, he is without peer.

THE LINDENWALD YEARS

Lindenwald was purchased by Van Buren in 1839. It is located in his hometown of Kinderhook. The estate covered over 200 acres at the time and was also a working farm. The centerpiece of the property is a Georgian Style Mansion that Van Buren transformed into his vision of an Italian Villa.

 The former President relished in his new surroundings. Here is a quote from Van Buren describing how he felt about his years at Lindenwald. He stated “The last and happiest days of my life, a farmer in my native town.”

Van Buren spent much of his last years traveling and was in high demand as a speaker at important events. He did make an attempt to regain the Presidency as a failed third party candidate in 1848. He also found the time to write a lengthy volume of memoirs. Martin Van Buren, “The Red Fox of Kinderhook” passed away on July 24th 1862. He was 79 years old.

Lindenwald is now a National Historical Site. Tours are given daily throughout most of the year, excluding the winter months. The home has been refurbished to the time of Van Buren’s occupancy. Many of his belongings and period furniture decorate the interior of the mansion. It’s about an hour’s drive from here and a worthwhile day trip for those who have an interest in the history of both our state and country.

A TRIP TO SARATOGA

Van Buren visited Saratoga Springs during his presidency. In the summer of 1839 he attended political meetings at the original United States Hotel on Broadway. It is not to be confused with its famous namesake that was built on the same site after an 1865 fire destroyed the original building.

Van Buren is one of several of our Presidents to have spent time here. George Washington, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Ulysses S. Grant, and Theodore Roosevelt are among those who also visited the city.

I hope you have enjoyed our look back at the life and times of Martin Van Buren. He is one of the select few who have guided this great country through the nearly two and a half centuries of its rise from a newborn nation to its status as leader of the free world.

VISITING LINDENWALD

The following is a link to the Martin Van Buren National Historic Site: www.nps.gov/nr/travel/presidents/van_buren_lindenwald.html

The Mystery of Benjamin Kissam Brotherson

Around 1800 Philip and Catharine Brotherson came into Blue Corners on the western edge of Charlton in Saratoga County. Over the next 40 years, their five children grew to maturity, the last being Benjamin Kissam Brotherson, born in 1819. At the age of sixteen, Benjamin was hired as a clerk for the dry goods merchant James Winne in Albany. During his time in Albany, he was known as an upstanding young man of good moral character. Only three years later, in 1838, he left his position in Albany and moved to New York City. Once in the city, he was hired by Union Bank, an institution that would be his employer for the next 20 years.

Over time the bank managers came to have the utmost confidence in this young man and gradually moved him into roles of greater responsibility. This confidence was not diminished when they found him often sought out to pay back small personal debts that he always seemed to be accumulating. Benjamin lived what outwardly was a frugal life, even living in a boarding house in the area that is now Greenwich Village.

In 1855, now 36 years old and with years of steady employment under his belt, Benjamin must have finally felt ready to take a wife. That August he married 25-year-old Anna Frances Robinson. Two years later Anna gave birth to a daughter, whom they named Adrian Francis. Unbeknownst to anyone but Benjamin and his wife, for over ten years he had been stealing tens of thousands of dollars from the bank and hiding the theft through false entries in the ledgers he kept as a head teller.

It was only through the curiosity of a New York City detective by the name of Joseph Keefe that questions were raised ultimately revealing Benjamin’s theft. While visiting Blakeman’s gambling house, Detective Keefe noticed the bank employee playing and losing large sums at a faro table. Bolstered by his suspicions, he kept watch over several weeks as Benjamin, who was known there as “Bob of the Union Bank,” bet and lost tens of thousands of dollars at various games of chance. After careful consideration, he approached the bank president with this discovery. The news was first met with disbelief that a long-time and highly trusted employee was involved in such questionable behavior. After a few days of deliberation within the bank leadership, it was decided to closely observe their employee for anything that would point to his dishonesty.

The increased scrutiny was quickly observed by Brotherson and complaining of a toothache, he left for lunch early and never returned. An examination of his books revealed that over the previous ten years he had taken as much as $140,000 from the bank. Soon after a warrant for his arrest was issued; it was reported that he had left the city on a ship headed to Panama in Central America. When questioned, his wife Anna was very cooperative with investigators, even freely giving evidence of her husband’s guilt that was published in the Auburn Weekly American on March 17, 1858: Brotherson’s wife converses freely regarding it, and stated to the lawyer who called upon her, that some years ago, previous to her marriage, B. told her that there was a defalcation in the Union Bank of $100,000, and asked her if she would marry him, knowing this fact. She consented and has faithfully kept his secret, but she says that it has worried him night and day and that he has repeatedly resolved to make a confession to the President but could not make sufficient courage. She says that B. asked for his pistol when he left, but seeing his excitement, she refused to let him have it, and he went away without it, telling her that she would not see him again for many years.

The investigation into Benjamin’s actions led the bank to Benjamin’s friend, Jacob Mott, a wealthy Wall Street stock trader. The scheme used by the two in removing the funds from the bank was quickly revealed and reported in the March 18, 1858, edition of the Litchfield Enquirer: Mr. Mott would make his deposits with the Receiving Teller; the Teller’s minutes were handed to Mr. Brotherson, who, instead of recording them correctly, would enter to Mr. Mott’s credit perhaps twice that sum, and Mr. Mott drew his checks upon the Bank accordingly. The money taken with the help of Mott was only part of what had been removed over the ten years that the thefts had been taking place, as Jacob Mott had opened an account at the bank only two years before the discovery. Surprisingly, after the initial reports of the theft and arrest of Mott, the matter seemed to have been dropped with no reports of the outcome in the weeks that followed.

At first, the bank announced that they would not pursue Brotherson, citing the reality that the funds had already been spent on gambling and he would have no means of making restitution. However, they quickly changed their mind and on March 24 of 1858, the bank announced a one-thousand-dollar reward for his apprehension. This reward was never paid out.

After Benjamin’s disappearance, his wife Anna went back to her maiden name, Robinson for both her and their daughter Adrian. In 1870 the two were living in a boarding house at 20 East 14th Street near 5th Avenue in New York City.

Where Benjamin fled is unknown, and his whereabouts for the next twenty years is a mystery. When Benjamin Kissam Brotherson surfaces for the last time he is beyond the reach of any penalty for his crime. On November 28, 1878, his brother John reported his death in the Saratoga Sentinel. Benjamin had died a few weeks earlier in Santa Barbara, CA, a place that John said Benjamin had gone two years before due to poor health.

Yet maybe there is a clue of his whereabouts for at least some of these years. In the early morning on Tuesday, May 3, 1870, a robbery was attempted at the First National Bank of Ballston Spa. The noise of the break-in was noticed almost immediately by those close by, as well as by a Mr. Brotherson, who according to a newspaper report “sleeps in the bank building, fired a gun twice and the village was alarmed.” Could this have been Benjamin, back in Saratoga County, hiding in plain sight all these years, and who, when finally, “found out” felt forced to move to the west coast?

Dave Waite is a resident of Blue Corners, Saratoga County and is a photographer and videographer.  He has written many articles on upstate New York history, including several in the recently published book, More Saratoga County Stories. Dave can be reached at davewaitefinearts@gmail.com

Saratoga’s Sam Hill

Sam Hill painting – Lawrence White Photography. Photo provided by The Saratoga County History Roundtable.

Though perhaps a dying proverb, “What in Sam Hill?!” used to be commonplace as an expression of exasperation. A quick internet search will point to several possible origin stories that explain where this phrase came from but, like most internet searches, the definitive truth remains elusive. Could it be that a county resident known by this common moniker contributed to this once-popular phrase?

An article published in the 1974 book Saratoga County Heritage relays an interesting story about a basket maker who lived in the Saratoga Springs area in the early 1800s. His name was Sam Hill, and the story, as told by author Milford Lester, plays out like this: Sam Hill lived in Splinterville (a hamlet in Greenfield near what is now the intersection of Route 9N and Middle Grove Road), so-called for the splints used to make baskets. Sam used to walk to Broadway carrying an armload of his wares to sell to the tourists visiting the mineral springs in the summer. He was an eccentric dresser and was asked by some patrons (one of whom was an artist) of the Union Hall Hotel if he would like to have his portrait painted. While Sam was reluctant at first, he agreed when offered a financial incentive. The finished portrait was then given to the hotel, where it hung in the office until the building was demolished, upon which it was moved to the Grand Union Hotel. Upon the demise of that hotel, it made its way into a private collection.

While this is an interesting story that has been passed down through generations of Saratogians, we have very little primary source documentation about the actual man. There is a Samuel Hill recorded on the 1820 Census in Greenfield, and in 1830 in Saratoga Springs. Exact ages were not provided on these early censuses, but there is a free white male recorded as being aged between 60-69 in 1830, which could possibly be the Sam Hill in the portrait. Another source comes in a notation in the diary of Daniel Benedict (Saratoga Springs) who relays that Mr. Sam Hill died on July 2, 1835 “at an advanced age.” This diary was later transcribed by Cornelius Durkee and serialized in the Saratoga Sentinel in the early 1880s. Commentary added at this later date included the statement, “He was the originator of the splint basket business which afterward became very widespread.”  In the aforementioned article by Milford Lester, he describes the coat worn by Sam Hill as “continental.”  While it is unclear whether or not this refers to a military uniform coat, Hill could have been at the right age to have fought in the American Revolution. If he did, any record of this could not be located. Other resources consulted including land records, mortgages and estate files have not turned up any further documentation about the life of Sam Hill.

Tradition also indicates Hill was a Native American, possibly Abenaki. There were other Native Americans living in this area, which had belonged to the Mohawks of the Haudenosaunee Nation in the not-to-distant past. By the end of the American Revolution in 1783, many of the Mohawk, who had sided with the British during the war, had already left this area. However, some Native Americans remained and found ways to survive in the new nation. One of these ways was by continuing to produce traditional native crafts to sell to the tourists who frequented Saratoga Springs, such as baskets. Rather than letting go of their culture to assimilate into a European society, they used this opportunity to continue their traditions and pass them down to future generations. In the mid-1800s, a seasonal Indian Encampment was set up in Congress Park, where people of Native American descent would come for the season, sell handmade crafts, and give demonstrations of traditional weapons, dances, and ceremonies. Observations by tourists show that this was a popular destination for those visiting the city and it continued for over 50 years, dissolving sometime in the early 1900s.

While it may seem that this article focuses heavily on the things we don’t know about Sam Hill, there is one extremely important artifact that does exist, his portrait. It is relatively rare for a portrait of a resident who was not wealthy to survive from this time period. Important context included in the painting are his clothing and the baskets he carried, giving us insight into what some of the craftsmen who frequented the spa might have looked like. Furthermore, we know that Sam Hill found a way to continue practicing a traditional craft and made a living from it, a craft that went on to become even more popular as evidenced by the splint factories that were built along Bell Brook and continued to thrive throughout the second half of the 19th century.

The William G. Pomeroy Foundation of Syracuse, NY is well known for funding thousands of historic markers across New York State and beyond. One of the marker programs they offer is the Legends and Lore Program, which recognizes the fact that not every story that relays information about a community’s past can be documented through primary sources. In 2022, the Saratoga County Historian’s Office received a grant from the William G. Pomeroy Foundation to erect a marker in Splinterville recognizing the story of Sam Hill as a Native American craftsman in the community. The marker was installed in November 2022 and is located at the intersection of Mill Road and Middle Grove Road in the Town of Greenfield, not far from where the splint factories used the water of Bell Brook to power their machines. While researching Sam Hill, I did not find any further information related to him being the originator of the proverbial “What in Sam Hill?” but perhaps his c. 1832 portrait is a better legacy of his contribution. 

Lauren Roberts is the Saratoga County Historian. She is co-host of the WAMC podcast A New York Minute in History, along with NYS Historian Devin Lander. Roberts co-produced the recently released documentary Harnessing Nature: Building the Great Sacandaga, which chronicles the creation of the Sacandaga Reservoir. You can reach Lauren at lroberts@saratogacountyny.gov

Taddeus Kosciusko – Hero of Two Worlds

Twin Bridges – Rt 87 Northway. Photo provided by The Saratoga County History Roundtable.

Ever since it opened to traffic on April 11, 1960, thousands of Saratoga County residents have daily passed over the Mohawk River on the Northway and think they are on the Twin Bridges. Few realize that the bridge is really named for one of America’s greatest heroes – Taddeus Kosciusko.

Tadeusz Kosciuszko (Taddeus Kosciusko is the Anglicized version) was born to minor Polish nobility on February 4, 1746 and educated at the School for Knights in Warsaw. There, he studied not only military science but also history, philosophy, Latin, French, German, geography, and engineering. He completed his studies in France attending lectures at the Academy of Fine Arts and at military schools.

Because Poland was dominated by its larger neighbors Prussia and Russia, ambitious young men such as Taddeus found opportunities lacking and so he immigrated to America in 1776. His military skills were sorely needed in the Continental Army which was composed mostly of farmers. He was immediately given a commission as a Colonel of Engineers and later promoted to head engineer of the Army.

He was soon attached to the Northern Army in response to Gen. “Gentleman Johnny” Burgoyne’s impending invasion from Canada. Assigned to assess the defenses of Fort Ticonderoga, he recommended that a battery of artillery be placed on Mount Independence. The commander foolishly ignored this advice and the British captured the Fort after they placed their artillery on Mount Independence. As the Americans retreated south from Fort Ti, Kosciusko destroyed bridges, felled trees and dammed streams thus providing the needed time to regroup and select a good defensive position from which to meet the enemy. That place was Saratoga.

Kosciusko’s array of defensive positions, particularly on Bemis Heights overlooking the Hudson River, frustrated the British Army when they attached on September 19 and again on October 7, 1777. When Burgoyne realized he could not proceed and was unable to return to Canada due to the approaching winter, he surrendered. General Gates, the Commander at Saratoga, later wrote that “the great tacticians of the campaign were the hills and forests which a young Polish engineer was skillful enough to select for my encampment.” If the Battle of Saratoga was the turning point of the American Revolution, then Taddeus Kosciusko was at the hub of the turn.

Other sites where Kosciusko applied his talents were at Peebles Island at the confluence of the Mohawk and the Hudson in Waterford and at West Point. His earthworks at Bemis Heights and Peebles Island can still be seen today while his plans for defending West Point were those that Benedict Arnold tried to sell to the British. After Saratoga, he transferred to the Southern Department as Chief Engineer and participated in most of the important battles in that area until Cornwallis’s surrender in 1781.

At the conclusion of the war, a grateful Continental Congress promoted him to Brigadier General, granted American citizenship and gave him a land grant. He was also admitted to the prestigious Society of the Cincinnati and the American Philosophical Society. Prior to returning to his native Poland, he wrote to his good friend Thomas Jefferson, “I hereby authorize my friend Thomas Jefferson to employ the whole thereof (his estate) in purchasing Negroes from among his own or any other and giving them liberty in my name”. To his shame, Jefferson neglected to carry out Kosciusko’s wishes. In Poland he led the opposition to Russian interference in the internal affairs of Poland. When war broke out with Russia (referred to as Kosciusko’s Uprising), he won many battles but eventually was wounded and captured. Released in 1796, he was destined to wander throughout Europe until his death in 1817.

The poet Byron said that “Kosciusko was that sound that crashes in a tyrant’s ear” and Jefferson pronounced him “as pure a son of liberty as I have ever known.” Next time you cross his bridge, shout out a hardy “Dziekuje” for our liberties.

Paul Perreault has been the Malta Town Historian since 2009. He served as principal in the Ballston Spa School District from 1978 until 1998 and as a history teacher at Shenendehowa High School from 1967 until 1975. He is the editor of the Gristmill, published quarterly by the Saratoga County History Center. Paul can be reached at historian@malta-town.org