SARATOGA SPRINGS — The Saratoga Springs School Board voted to approve a resolution that reaffirmed the district’s support for, among other things, DEI policies and transgender students’ ability to participate in sports consistent with their gender identity.
At a Mar. 27 meeting, seven board members voted in support of the resolution. One opposed it, and another abstained from voting.
Board member Dr. Connie Woytowich said she abstained due to the resolution being a “political act” that could create deeper division in the community and put the district at odds with federal regulations. Dean A. Kolligian Jr. was the lone “no” vote.
Board member Dr. Deborah Amory said the district’s lawyers reviewed the resolution prior to the vote and found it to be “certainly legal.” The lawyers recommended some minor edits to the resolution, which Amory and several other board members addressed.
Prior to the vote, students, parents, and community members offered their thoughts during public comment periods. Most speakers supported the resolution.
One transgender student said that the federal government was targeting trans people and that school board members who voted “yes” were “brave.”
A parent who opposed the resolution said that his daughter on a track and field team won’t compete due to transgender students being allowed to play on teams consistent with their gender identity.
A district resident who called the issue of transgender people in sports “touchy” and “not clear-cut,” said she still supported the resolution as a whole because kids “need to know” that grownups “have got their backs.”
A parent with two daughters in the district said swimming record times showed that biological male high schoolers significantly outperformed biological female college athletes. As a result, she called for delaying a vote on the sports-related section of the resolution.
Superintendent of Schools Dr. Michael Patton responded to comments about trans athletes, saying that the New York State Public High School Athletic Association has already established guidelines for transgender students that all districts in the state must follow. Those guidelines state that students should be placed on teams that most align with the student’s gender identity.
News of the resolution attracted national attention in the days preceding the vote, when the popular conservative X account “Libs of TikTok” accused the Saratoga Springs School District of supporting “radical gender ideology” in a post that garnered more than 237,000 views. The account also retweeted a post from the local conservative blog Moving Saratoga Forward that listed the names and emails of Saratoga School Board members.
The resolution, titled “Affirming Our Support for Every Student,” states, among other things, that the Board of Education would:
reaffirm its support for the district’s policy and regulation 0105 titled “Equity, Inclusivity, and Diversity in Education”;
uphold New York State laws safeguarding vulnerable populations and not comply with directives that violate civil rights protections;
affirm that every student has a right to an education regardless of immigration status, and that law enforcement officers may not question students on school property except under very specific conditions;
respect students’ chosen names and pronouns while also ensuring their right to use facilities and participate in activities and sports consistent with their gender identity.
The resolution appeared to be a clear attempt to combat several Trump administration policies that threaten to rescind federal funds from educational institutions that don’t comply with the president’s orders. According to Board Vice President Tony Krackeler, $3.1 million of the district’s 2024-25 budget came from the federal government. All of those funds, Krackeler said, are only amendable by an act of Congress.