Camping Ordinance Approved During Turbulent City Council Meeting
SARATOGA SPRINGS — After over three hours of impassioned public hearings and discussion by commissioners, the Saratoga Springs City Council passed an ordinance that bans ‘camping’ on most public property.
The ordinance would restrict laying, sitting, or placing ‘camping gear’ on streets, gazeboes, benches, and in the entryway of buildings. Under the ordinance, violators would receive a verbal or written warning followed by an initial fine of $100 and subsequent fines of $250. The ordinance doesn’t apply to parks, as those operate under pre-established rules.
The measure was spearheaded by Public Safety Commissioner Tim Coll, who said he modeled the ordinance on one passed in Grants Pass, Oregon, which was upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court in 2024.
The ordinance passed 3-2, with Republican Mayor John Safford and Public Works Commissioner Chuck Marshall voting with Coll to pass it. Democratic Commissioners Dillion Moran and Minita Sanghvi voted against it.
Before the meeting, the City Council held a public hearing on the ordinance, during which over 40 individuals spoke on the matter for more than three hours. Council chambers were at full capacity, with 25 people having to wait in the hallway to get a chance to speak. While Mayor Safford attempted to keep comments to a maximum of two minutes, many speakers exceeded this limit, prompting a few warnings from the mayor. He also issued warnings to several activists who voiced their opposition to the measure from the gallery.
One person, a local homeless advocate, spoke for over 30 minutes. After the mayor repeatedly warned them to sit down and called for a five-minute adjournment, the individual was arrested and charged with disorderly conduct. They were issued an appearance ticket and released by police.
Opinions on the ordinance were varied. While most speakers during the hearing opposed the ordinance, Commissioner Coll presented letters from the Saratoga Springs Downtown Business Association (DBA) and the Downtown Special Assessment District in support of the ordinance. He also stated that of the emails he received through public comment, 12 were opposed to the ordinance, while 15 were in favor.
In their letter, which was sent to Saratoga TODAY before the meeting, the DBA emphasized the importance of accessible sidewalks and clear parking garages for residents, visitors, and individuals with disabilities. Their viewpoint was supported by two of the speakers, who stated that they had to deal with harassment, human waste, and property damage caused by people on the street, particularly in the early mornings and late at night.
On the other side, reasons for opposition varied widely. The council heard from former and current homeless individuals, advocates, lawyers, community members, and some who quoted scripture.
Some people supported the ordinance but thought it needed more time for public comment and tweaking by city council. Others argued that it was too vague and could open the city up to litigation. Many described the plight of those trying to seek shelter through county services and the roadblocks they faced along the way, as well as the human side of the issue. A common thread among those who spoke was a lack of resources for people experiencing homelessness and housing insecurity in Saratoga County.
Their opposition was backed by the New York Civil Liberties Union, whose Capitol Region Director, Melanie Trimble, spoke at the meeting. She disagreed with the discretion it gave police officers and how vague it was, warning that such issues could lead to it being overturned. She said NYCLU would be watching the ordinance.
It wasn’t just the public who participated in the debate. Commissioners Coll and Moran traded barbs over the ordinance. At the same time, Commissioner Sanghvi accused the mayor of interrupting her when she tried to ask questions about the ordinance and his comments.
Things got so heated that an attempt to vote on the ordinance had to be redone because the Commissioners were still debating when the mayor called a vote, leading to confusion over whether it was enacted or not. After a brief adjournment, the vote was redone and passed 3-2.
Saratoga Springs isn’t the first jurisdiction in the county to enact restrictions on camping. The Town of Waterford unanimously passed a similar ordinance in June banning camping outside of designated areas and imposing jail terms and fines for offenders.


























